Human Impact on Salmon
Purpose:
This lesson encourages students to discover the ways in which humans
affect salmon, both positively and negatively.
Curriculum Match:
British Columbia, Science, Grade 4-7
Grade 4: It is expected that students will:
- use a variety of media to present information (Applications
of Science)
- discuss how changes in an organism's habitat can affect the
survival of individual organisms and entire species (Life Science)
- relate the growth and survival of organisms to a variety of
conditions (Life Science)
- relate the life processes of an organism to its use of nutrients,
water, and oxygen (Life Science)
- outline the importance of water for life (Earth and Space Science)
Grade 5: It is expected that students will:
- identify living resources in the local environment (Life Science)
- describe the known and potential environmental impacts of using
B.C.'s living
- resources (Life Science)
- describe the environmental impacts of using non-living resources
(Earth and Space Science)
Grade 7: It is expected that students will:
- analyze costs and benefits of alternative scientific choices
related to a community problem (Applications of Science)
- describe all organisms in terms of their roles as part of interconnected
food webs (Life Science)
- describe ways in which species interact with each other (Life
Science)
- determine the limiting factors for local ecosystems (Life Science)
- outline factors that influence the length and quality of life
(Life Science)
Time: 1-2 hours, plus out-of-class time as required
Materials:
calculators (optional)
Resources:Salmon
Facts (see menu)
Student handout:
Salmon Countdown (bottom of page)
Additional print and non-print resources related to salmon -- see
recommended resources for B.C.
Preparation:
Please review the procedures and resources used in this activity.
Procedure:
(If you have not conducted the Salmon Life Cycle lesson)
Begin with a class discussion
of what students already know about salmon. Encourage students to
volunteer any experiences they have had with salmon (for example,
seeing salmon swimming in a river, a visit to a hatchery, a family
fishing trip). Use a KWL chart (Know, Wonder, Learn) to record students'
responses. Use prompts as necessary to encourage students to think
about the different aspects of the topic, such as:
- the different species of salmon
- animals that rely on salmon for food
- salmon habitat requirements
- human use of salmon
Record what students know to be facts in the Know column. Record
questions in the Wonder column. Save this chart and add to it throughout
the unit as students learn about salmon.
Continue the discussion by focussing on the ways in which humans
and salmon interact. Record any new items to the KWL chart. For
example:
- humans eat salmon
- humans cause pollution to salmon habitats
- urbanization destroys salmon habitats
- salmon hatcheries increase salmon populations
- fish ladders help salmon overcome physical obstacles
Distribute the handout, Salmon Countdown (bottom of page), and
allow a few minutes for students to complete the worksheet individually
or in pairs. If you have not completed the Salmon Life Cycle lesson,
you may need to refer students to the Salmon Facts resources (see
menu) for information on each stage of the life cycle.
When the activity is finished, debrief as a class:
How many of the 7000 eggs actually survived all the way to the spawning
phase? (The answer is 2)... Did this surprise you?
Compare how many salmon survived from each stage. When did the greatest
number of salmon die? Why?
Even though few salmon survive to spawn, it is still successful
reproduction if only 2 spawners from one nest return to lay eggs.
Why?
Focus on each item on the Salmon Countdown worksheet, one by one.
For each, ask students whether or not the interaction involves humans.
Encourage them to think of both direct and indirect influences.
For example, when the alevins were destroyed under the cows' hooves,
point out that if the farmer had maintained his fence, the alevins
would not have been destroyed.
Ask: If you removed all of the dangers caused by humans, would
the numbers change?
If so, how? What effect might this have on the salmon? On species
that depend on the salmon?
Continue the discussion by asking students to suggest other threats
to salmon that were not presented in the handout. Point out that
disease and climate can also damage salmon populations.
Next, ask students to brainstorm what humans can do to help salmon
populations. Record their responses. If not included in students'
suggestions, introduce the following initiatives:
- hatcheries
- fish farms
- habitat restoration
Divide the class into groups. Have each group use the suggested
resources to research one of the salmon enhancement initiatives.
Set the parameters of the final product (e.g., oral report, written,
graphic, multimedia), and ensure students are clear about the task.
Students' reports could include any or all of the following information:
- examples of the initiative and how it worked
- associated costs
- positive and negative impacts
- other plant and animal species involved
When students have completed their projects, provide an opportunity
for them to share their findings with the rest of the class. Allow
time for questions. Debrief by adding any new information to the
class KWL chart.
Assessment:
Use an observation sheet to assess students as they work in their
groups. Look for evidence that they:
- work co-operatively
- follow directions
- use group time efficiently and productively to complete assignments
to the best of their ability
- identify requested information and share it with others
As a class, set criteria for assessing the group projects. Have
students conduct a peer and self-assessment of their work based
on the set criteria. Criteria could include:
- clarity of information
- organization
- accuracy
- thoroughness
- appropriate citation of sources
Adaptations:
The reading level of the resources used in this lesson may be too
advanced for some grade 4 or 5 students. Use contextual support
and/or reading buddies as necessary to facilitate student comprehension
of the materials. For younger students or if resources are limited,
the research and report activity can be altered, or replaced with
a guided reading strategy of the Salmon Facts resources.
Extensions:
For an interactive illustration of the effects of humans on salmon
populations, have students play the Salmon Challenge game. Using
the resources in Salmon Facts (see menu) focus on the controversial
issue of salmon farms. Have students research and prepare a debate
on the effects of salmon farms, such as "Be it resolved that
salmon farming is beneficial to the survival of all salmon species".
Ask the students to conduct interviews with their family or friends
who have lived in the area for a long time. Interviews should focus
on a comparison between the state of salmon populations now and
in the past. As students present their interview results, encourage
them to focus on why salmon populations have changed. What human
activities have affected the salmon populations? What can humans
do to reverse any negative effects?
Have your class make presentations to a buddy class; or, have the
class teach one-on-one or two-on-two with younger buddies. Suggest
appropriate preparations, work pages and resources that they can
use. Consider appropriate and timely field trips.
***
The following may be copied onto separate pages to hand out.
SALMON COUNTDOWN
Pacific salmon have to face many dangers on their journey from
an egg to adulthood. To investigate how many salmon will make it
through their life cycle to spawn, follow the journey of these sibling
salmon. This example looks at how many salmon will survive from
one redd, or nest area. Many females will lay eggs in several nests.
A female pacific salmon has returned to her home stream to spawn.
She lays 5500 eggs in several small nests.
Male salmon come along ready to fertilize the eggs, but one-tenth
of the eggs (550) do not get fertilized. This leaves ________ fertilized
eggs in the nests that have now been properly covered with gravel
by the female.
As the eggs are developing over the winter, a new road is constructed
further up the stream. Lots of loose soil is left behind. A large
rainstorm washes gravel, mud, and silt into the river. Nests upstream
have been totally smothered. At this point in the stream, 800 eggs
from this group are smothered and killed. The remaining eggs hatch
into alevins that stay hidden in the gravel for another month. There
are now ________ alevins.
This stream runs through a farmer's land. He has been very busy
making sure that the fences are repaired, but one of the fences
has fallen down. The farmer's dairy cows have waded onto the gravel
bar in the stream to drink the water. 1020 alevins are killed under
the cows' hooves. The number of remaining alevins is ________.
A brother and a sister are helping their father paint the house.
When they are finished, they pour the unused paint into a storm
drain next to their driveway. The drain empties directly into the
stream and kills 530 alevins. There are now ________ alevins.
The remaining alevins become fry and swim up out of the gravel.
After two weeks the small fry begin their journey downstream to
the ocean. People who live close to the streams have been using
lots of chemicals on their lawns and gardens this year. Each time
it rains, more chemical is washed into the river, which kills 245
salmon. Now there are ________ salmon to travel to the ocean. These
salmon are called smolts and are silvery in colour.
The salmon smolts finally reach the ocean. As juveniles, they try
to avoid predators, but 1430 of them are eaten by seagulls, mackerel,
and other fish. This leaves ________ salmon.
As adults in the open ocean, killer whales feed on the group and
500 more are lost. There are now ________ salmon.
People like to eat salmon! Commercial fishing boats in the ocean
using different nets catch 375 of the sibling salmon. This leaves
________ of the original salmon to begin the journey home.
As the salmon swim upstream toward the spawning grounds, hungry
eagles and bears eagerly eat 24 salmon as they pass by. The bears
will use the fat and protein the salmon provide to help them through
the long winter's hibernation. ________ salmon are left to continue
the journey.
Recreational sport fishers catch another 14 salmon. This leaves
________ salmon to travel up the fish ladder constructed around
a dam.
The remaining salmon are tired and have traveled a long way. The
final leg of the journey brings them to a waterfall. The salmon
have to jump the falls to make it to the spawning grounds. Some
of the salmon are too tired and 4 die. ________ salmon arrive at
the place where they were born.
These mature salmon have
arrived at their home stream to spawn and it seems as if they will
be successful!
But a family out walking
through the woods has come over to the stream to see the salmon
run. They have let their dog run through the riverbed. What happens
to the remaining salmon? Do they die before spawning? Or do they
survive to produce a new generation of salmon?
You decide:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|