Turtles Without Borders: A Tri-National Approach To Marine Conservation

Landmark U.S. Legislation Aids An International Sea Turtle Conservation Effort Under The NAFTA Treaty

June 15, 2004

By Andy Torr, AquaNews Editor

Under cover of night, an endangered leatherback turtle lays her eggs on a beach.

Photo: The Ocean Conservancy

Endangered sea turtles received a new level of federal protection this week as the U.S. House of Representatives passed a landmark Marine Turtle Conservation Act. The bipartisan bill authorizes an annual sum of USD $5 million in support of international conservation efforts to protect sea turtles and their habitat. The funding will also help to combat illegal trade in sea turtle shells, meat and eggs.

"This bill is a triumph for sea turtles," said Marydele Donnelly, a sea turtle biologist with The Ocean Conservancy who testified before Congress in April in support of the legislation. "From Africa to Asia to Latin America, dedicated biologists and community activists are working under difficult and dangerous conditions to save sea turtles from extinction. Tonight, on beaches around the world, poachers armed with machetes will butcher turtles coming ashore to nest. Some of these animals will be 30-40 year old animals nesting for the very first time. The bill will provide funding to stop this killing," she said.

Sea turtles urgently need international protection. Their long lives, international migration routes and late reproductive ages make them extremely vulnerable to poaching, fishing, pollution and other human activities. Six of the world's seven sea turtle species are listed under the U.S. Endangered Species Act, including the colossal leatherback, one of the world's largest reptiles.

The Marine Turtle Conservation Act focuses on nesting populations of sea turtles beyond US borders. By authorizing funding for international programs through 2008, it aims to foster long-term research and protection of nesting populations, involving and educating local communities about conservation, providing economic alternatives to egg-and-turtle harvesting, and helping to enforce existing laws that protect sea turtles.

Turtles Without Borders

Have you seen a leatherback turtle in BC? Click here to report a sighting.

The timing of the new bill is especially relevant to an international sea turtle conservation effort currently underway by the North American Commission for Environmental Cooperation (CEC). Established by Canada, Mexico and the United States under the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), the CEC consists of a small committee of environmental experts appointed by each government. Its aim is to promote cooperation between the three countries in implementing the North American Agreement on Environmental Cooperation (NAAEC), a lesser-known but far-reaching environmental side accord to the NAFTA treaty.

A key section of the NAAEC side accord is the so-called biodiversity resolution, which recognizes the intricate links and interdependence between the three countries through “species and spaces of common concern.” One species of common concern, the leatherback sea turtle, has been selected as one of three “icon” animals that will benefit from a tri-national approach to marine conservation.

“The section of Pacific ocean stretching from Baja, Mexico to Alaska’s Bering Sea is home to hundreds of leatherback sea turtles whose range, distribution and migratory pattern requires them to spend time in the sovereign waters of three different countries,” said Patrick O’Callaghan, Vice-President of Conservation and Education at the Vancouver Aquarium. O’Callaghan is the CEC’s tri-national species lead for the North American Leatherback Turtle Conservation Action Plan.

“Protecting such an animal requires a co-operative approach that uses a broader perspective and considers more than any one country’s needs or jurisdiction,” said O’Callaghan. “Regardless of the origin of the turtles, the NAAEC accord encourages each country to do whatever it can, acting in concert with the other two countries, to help conserve the species. More importantly, the accord brings to bear the combined political clout of all three countries when addressing international marine conservation issues.”

Tri-National Approach to Conservation

Humpback whales and an endangered seabird, the pink-footed shearwater, have also been selected as "icon" species for conservation.

A similar tri-national approach to marine conservation is being applied to the other two North American “icon” species, humpback whales and pink-footed shearwaters (a type of seabird).


As marine species, the three selected face a variety of threats associated with unsustainable fishing practices. The leatherback turtle, for instance, is frequently entangled in pelagic longline fishing gear, which can stretch 40-60 miles in a single set. Humpback whales are also threatened by fishing gear entanglement and ship collisions, although there are new fears regarding food availability and noise pollution. Likewise, the pink-footed shearwater, which migrates from Chile to Alaska, is vulnerable to longline entanglement and potential food source depletion as a result of fishing practices.

The NAAEC accord emphasizes the cascading effect that loss of biodiversity has on environments and economies - effects that are first felt locally, then nationally and regionally. Because the effects of ecological damage in one country can affect neighboring countries, each country is encouraged under the NAFTA treaty to act in ways that mitigate the negative effects of trade on the environment.

"Canada, Mexico and the United States are committed to protecting the leatherback turtle, humpback whale and pink-footed shearwater within the next five years," said Hans Herrmann, head of the Conservation of Biodiversity program at the CEC. "Migratory species do not recognize national boundaries, and hence depend upon coordinated conservation policies for their survival."

The U.S. Marine Turtle Conservation Act exemplifies the spirit of stewardship and cooperation in which the NAAEC accord and the NAFTA treaty were signed. According to Maryland Congressman Wayne Gilchrest, who sponsored the bill in the House of Representatives, the Act “will not itself stop the slaughter of sea turtles or their eggs, but it sends a powerful message to the world community that the United States strongly supports their conservation and will not allow these species to disappear forever.”

A bill similar to the Marine Turtle Conservation Act was passed in the Senate in October 2003. However, small differences between the Senate and House versions need to be resolved before President Bush can sign the bill into law. Experts anticipate this resolution will happen in the near future. Efforts are currently underway to ensure that startup funding for the bill is made available in the Fiscal Year 2005 budget, which runs from October 1, 2004 through September 30, 2005.

In the meantime, the important work of the CEC continues. Currently, the Commission is preparing a North American Conservation Action Plan for each species. The plans, which outline conservation opportunities for each species that would be assisted by tri-national cooperation, will go to CEC commissioners from each country and ultimately, their federal governments.

 

For more information on the CEC's efforts to conserve sea turtles and other species, click here.


© 2003-2006 Vancouver Aquarium. All rights reserved.
Read our Terms and Conditions of Use | Privacy Policy